California’s Gold Rush is definitely a fascinating period of American history. Tales of fortunes made and lost, lawlessness, violence and tragedy provide plenty of material for a documentary. Add to this the possibility that some of those who lived and died during those turbulent times might still be hanging around, and you’d think we’d have all the ingredients here for some creepy storytelling.

Unfortunately, while Ghosts of the Gold Rush has some interesting stories to tell, I was left wondering what exactly it was trying to achieve. Directed by Brandon Alvis, the documentary takes us to several historic locations associated with California’s Gold Rush, combining interviews with local historians, hotel employees and paranormal investigators, alongside a smattering of archive footage and dramatic reconstructions.

We begin in Placerville, formerly known as Hangtown, a name apparently earned through the public hangings that took place there during its rather violent past. It’s a gorgeous-looking town that certainly appears to have retained much of that old frontier appearance, and our first major location is the historic Cary House Hotel.

Here, employees and guests recount various experiences involving unexplained footsteps, fleeting shadows, strange smells and lights behaving in ways they cannot explain. We hear about the Lavender Lady, the Weeping Woman and a particular room supposedly associated with more paranormal activity than others.

Those recounting their experiences come across as perfectly credible in the way they tell their stories. Nobody appears to be desperately trying to convince us that they’ve witnessed something extraordinary, and there’s a naturalness to their accounts.

But here’s the problem. Haven’t we heard all this before in numerous other paranormal documentaries?

Footsteps when nobody is there, shadows glimpsed out of the corner of an eye, unexplained scents and rooms that apparently make people feel uncomfortable. These are familiar ingredients of countless paranormal documentaries, and Ghosts of the Gold Rush doesn’t really bring anything new to them.

From Placerville, we move to the Kennedy Mine and the nearby Argonaut Mine, where a devastating fire in 1922 resulted in the deaths of 47 miners trapped underground.

This is probably where I found the historical material most interesting. The scale of the tragedy, the rescue attempts and the eventual recovery of the miners’ bodies provide a genuinely sobering backdrop to the stories being told.

Members of the Kennedy Mine Paranormal Project describe alleged experiences around the site, including unexplained knocking, shadowy figures and visitors suddenly becoming overwhelmed with emotion.

Various theories are suggested. Could the spirits of the miners remain? Might the minerals or the land itself somehow contribute to the experiences people report? Again, these are personal accounts and possibilities rather than anything established as fact, and the documentary largely leaves us to make up our own minds.

There is also some black-and-white archive footage of miners and the surrounding landscape, although I couldn’t determine whether this was specifically connected to the locations being discussed or simply representative footage from the period. Nevertheless, it adds a little historical atmosphere.

Our final destination is Auburn, where another group of paranormal enthusiasts recount local legends, alleged sightings and a particularly unpleasant story involving a family murder that may have been connected to the discovery of gold.

The historic courthouse also receives attention as another supposedly haunted location.
And then the documentary ends.

I sat there for a moment thinking, well, what was the point of all that?
I don’t mean that disrespectfully towards those who contributed their experiences. But I wanted to hear some genuinely spine-tingling tales, perhaps backed up by some tangible images or unexplained things caught on camera. Unfortunately, there was none of that, and that’s OK if there’s something else to grab my attention and satisfy my longing for some truly creepy and atmospheric viewing.
Recording local history and the stories passed down through generations is a perfectly worthwhile undertaking, but it’s not necessarily what one might be expecting when settling down to watch a documentary that presents itself as a journey into the supernatural.
But as a paranormal documentary, Ghosts of the Gold Rush offers very little that distinguishes it from countless others covering supposedly haunted locations.
The contributors generally speak convincingly, the locations are interesting to look at and the combination of interviews, archive material and reconstructions keeps things moving reasonably well.
What it doesn’t do, at least for me, is generate anything approaching a sense of fear or unease.
I didn’t find it scary. I didn’t find it creepy. And despite the tragic histories associated with some of these places, I never felt that the documentary managed to turn its collection of stories into something particularly compelling.
It relies so heavily on people recounting experiences rather than developing any of them beyond the initial anecdote, that by the time we reach Auburn, we’re hearing much the same sort of accounts we’ve encountered at both the Cary House and the mine.
Ghosts of the Gold Rush isn’t without merit. There’s some interesting local history here, the contributors seem sincere and the locations provide an attractive backdrop.
But ultimately, it felt like a collection of familiar ghost stories connected by a historical theme rather than a documentary with anything especially revealing to say.
I finished watching with a little more knowledge of California’s Gold Rush history, but no greater sense of mystery, intrigue or unease.
And I was still left asking myself: what was the point?

HorrorBuzz Score
4/10
Rating: 4
Runtime: 65 min.
Genre: Documentary
Directed By: Brandon Alvis

Share This Story

Author

Craig Wade brings HorrorBuzz readers reviews fresh off the festival circuit, including Beyond Fest.

More from Craig