Headless Horseman Hayrides & Haunted Houses runs its full Halloween-season schedule again in 2026 across 65 wooded acres in Ulster Park, New York, in the heart of Washington Irving’s Hudson Valley. With 14 named attractions — the richest lineup in this entire batch — from a witch-run candy company to a cursed corn maze, we had plenty of distinct rooms to pair.
We matched all ten of this year’s headline attractions with the horror films that best capture their spirit.
This list was checked against streaming availability as of today; platforms shift constantly, so if a link goes cold, check JustWatch for the latest.
1. The Crazies (2010) — for The Cursed Earth of Crow Hollow
Crow Hollow’s cursed ground and its effect on the local population pairs with this remake about a small town whose water supply is contaminated by a military bioweapon, turning ordinary neighbors into something violent and unrecognizable.
A small-town sheriff watches his community unravel as a mysterious contaminant turns residents increasingly violent and irrational — a tense, well-made remake of Romero’s original with real dread underneath the carnage.
Watch it: The Roku Channel | Plex
2. The Witch (2016) — for Jacko’s Inferno
A witch house attraction calls for Robert Eggers’ slow-burn folk-horror breakout — a Puritan family exiled to the edge of the New England wilderness begins to suspect something supernatural, and possibly one of their own, is responsible for a series of horrors.
A devout family is banished to an isolated farm at the edge of the woods, where a series of unexplainable tragedies convinces them a witch is hunting their household — meticulously researched, dread-soaked period horror.
3. The Love Witch (2016) — for Widow’s Walk
Widow’s Walk’s murderous, rose-obsessed widow pairs with this stylish homage to 1960s technicolor horror about a beautiful witch who uses spells and potions to make men fall hopelessly in love with her — with fatal results every time.
A modern witch obsessed with being loved uses magic to enchant a string of men, each of whom meets a grim end once the spell takes hold — a gorgeous, deliberately retro throwback with real bite underneath the style.
Watch it: The Roku Channel | Plex
4. The Wicker Man (1973) — for Crow Hollow Candy Company
An idyllic small town hiding a very dark secret is the exact premise of this British horror landmark — a police officer investigates a girl’s disappearance on a remote island, only to discover the entire community is hiding something far more sinister than a crime.
A devout police sergeant travels to a remote Scottish island to investigate a missing child, and uncovers a pagan community whose traditions have a horrifying purpose for outsiders — a genre landmark that still holds up as genuinely unsettling.
5. Psycho (1960) — for Skinner Motel
The name says it all — Alfred Hitchcock’s genre-defining thriller about a woman on the run who checks into an isolated motel run by a deeply disturbed young man and his “mother” remains the single most influential motel-horror story ever told.
A secretary on the run stops for the night at the Bates Motel, run by a shy young man under the domineering influence of his mother — the film that essentially invented the modern horror thriller.
6. The Green Inferno (2014) — for Glutton’s Diner and Slaughter House
This diner-and-slaughterhouse combo calls for cannibal horror’s most notorious modern entry — Eli Roth’s throwback to 1970s and ’80s “cannibal film” shockers, kept distinct from every other meatpacking pairing in this national batch.
A group of student activists on a rainforest expedition are captured by an isolated tribe that turns out to practice cannibalism — brutal, unflinching throwback to 1970s and ’80s cannibal horror.
7. Drag Me to Hell (2009) — for Rose’s Swamp Shack
Rose’s Swamp Shack’s fatal fortune-telling calls for Sam Raimi’s gleefully nasty return to horror — a loan officer who denies an elderly woman’s mortgage extension finds herself cursed by a demonic entity with a very specific, very grim timeline.
A bank loan officer is cursed by a vengeful gypsy woman after denying her a loan extension, and has three days to break the curse before being dragged to hell by a demonic entity — over-the-top, gleefully gross horror-comedy.
Watch it: The Roku Channel | Plex
8. Dark Harvest (2023) — for Evil Reaping: Dark Harvest Corn Maze
This is as direct a title match as this list gets — a horror-thriller adaptation of Norman Partridge’s novel about a small Midwestern town’s annual ritual sacrifice to a monstrous scarecrow-like entity that rises from the cornfields every Halloween.
Every Halloween, a small town’s teenage boys are sent to hunt down a monstrous entity that rises from the cornfields — the winner earns a scholarship out of town, and everyone else stays trapped in the cycle for another year.
9. Freaks (1932) — for Lucy Fear’s Circus Side Show
A sideshow attraction calls for Tod Browning’s controversial pre-Code classic, which cast real sideshow performers in a story about a conniving trapeze artist who learns not to underestimate the “freaks” she plans to exploit.
A gold-digging trapeze artist schemes to marry a wealthy sideshow performer for his inheritance, unaware that the tight-knit circus community protects its own — a landmark, once-banned classic that remains genuinely unsettling.
10. Sleepy Hollow (1999) — for The Horseman’s Tomb
The attraction’s namesake gets its definitive on-screen anchor — Tim Burton’s gothic, gorgeously stylized take on Washington Irving’s original legend, with Christopher Walken as a suitably terrifying Headless Horseman.
A New York City constable is sent to investigate a series of murders in a small Dutch village, all committed by a headless horseman who rides out from the woods each night — Tim Burton’s gothic style applied to the ultimate Hudson Valley legend.
Watch it: Plex | Paramount+
Headless Horseman Hayrides & Haunted Houses runs its full schedule through Halloween season 2026 in Ulster Park, New York. Build your watch list, then head into the Hudson Valley for the legend’s original home turf.
Get your tickets to Headless Horseman Hayrides & Haunted Houses
